Preview buildPrices are indicative. Hospital records have not yet been checked by phone with each hospital, and the agency ratings are sample data.
Analysis

Is treatment in China 60–80% cheaper? How to check

Is medical treatment in China really 60–80% cheaper? Check which prices are compared, add travel and time off work, and see when the saving holds up.

Key points

  • A percentage saving means little until you know which two prices are being compared.
  • The saving that counts is measured against what you would pay at home. A foreign list price is the wrong baseline.
  • Savings tend to be largest on high-cost, self-pay treatment and smallest on short, cheap procedures.

Almost every site that promotes treatment abroad carries a line such as “60–80% cheaper than at home”. The claim is not always false. For some treatments, for some patients, the difference in the hospital bill is of that order. But a percentage comes from dividing one price by another, and the claim rarely says which two prices were used.

China can be markedly cheaper for some treatments and some patients, and it is not uniformly cheaper. A headline percentage tells you more about the marketing than about your bill. The figures on this site are indicative ranges, and they will not settle the question for you either. What they can do is show how the sum works, so this article follows one case through with them.

The illustration: a knee replacement in Shanghai

The case below is illustrative. It uses the indicative ranges published on our treatment and city pages, in US dollars, and describes no real patient. Your own quotes will differ.

Our page for a total knee replacement gives these hospital-bill ranges:

Where Indicative range
China $8,000–22,000
United Kingdom $15,000–21,000
United States $20,000–45,000

The same page gives 4–7 days in hospital, 21–28 nights in the country in total, and 21 days before flying home. Our Shanghai page puts a mid-range hotel at about $95 a night.

Step 1. See where a headline percentage comes from.

Set the bottom of the China range against the top of the US range: $8,000 against $45,000. China comes out about 82% cheaper. That is the kind of figure that ends up in an advertisement.

The “home” figure in a savings claim is often a list price at a private hospital in the United States, where published charges are high and few patients pay them in full. Set against the cheapest ward in a Chinese public hospital, it produces a striking percentage that describes almost nobody’s situation. The lower end of a China range usually reflects a standard ward and a domestically made implant; the upper end reflects an international ward and an imported one.

Step 2. Choose your real baseline.

The comparison that matters sets what you would pay for this treatment at home against what you would pay, in total, to have it in China. For a resident of a country with a public health system, the cost at home may be nothing except waiting time. For someone with insurance, it is the excess and co-payments. For someone paying for themselves, it is a private quote. Those are three different baselines.

In this illustration the patient would otherwise pay privately in the United Kingdom, and our UK range of $15,000–21,000 stands in for that private quote.

Step 3. Make the two quotes describe the same thing.

Before any subtraction, check five things. An insurer’s negotiated rate is not the price a self-paying patient is quoted, so compare your own out-of-pocket cost in each place. In joint replacement the implant is a large part of the bill, and a quote based on a domestically made implant is not comparable with one based on an imported brand; ask for the manufacturer and model in both quotes. A public hospital’s ordinary ward, its international department and a private hospital can charge different prices for the same operation, as our comparison of international departments and private hospitals explains. One quote may cover pre-operative tests, anaesthesia, the stay, medicines and the first follow-up, while another is the surgeon’s and theatre fee alone. And practice on length of stay differs between countries: a longer stay may be included in one price and replaced by outpatient physiotherapy, billed separately, in another.

Our guide to what affects the price covers these factors in more detail.

Step 4. Add the cost of being there.

Accommodation before admission and during recovery, until you are fit to fly, is the one travel cost our pages let us put a number on. With 21–28 nights in the country and 4–7 of them in hospital, the patient needs a hotel for between 14 and 24 nights. At $95 a night that is $1,330–2,280.

A week’s extra stay, as a contingency, adds $665 in lodging alone.

That gives an illustrative total of $9,995 at the low end ($8,000 + $1,330 + $665) and $24,945 at the high end ($22,000 + $2,280 + $665).

Step 5. Compare the totals in money.

Against the UK range of $15,000–21,000, the low-end China total is about $5,000 below the bottom of the UK range. The high-end China total, with an imported implant and an international ward, is about $3,900 above the top of it.

Neither figure yet includes the costs below, which the illustration leaves out because they depend on where you live and who comes with you:

  • return flights, often for two people;
  • a visa, if you need one, and travel insurance that covers planned treatment, which standard policies commonly exclude;
  • interpreting and any agency service fee;
  • local transport and meals for a companion;
  • time away from work for you and your companion, which for many households is the largest hidden cost;
  • follow-up at home, which you may need to pay for privately if the local service will not take over care begun elsewhere;
  • any extra hospital charges in a longer stay or a complication, beyond the lodging counted above.

So the same treatment, with the same ranges, can be thousands cheaper or thousands dearer, and the advertised 82% has shrunk to a figure that may be zero.

How the answer changes in other cases

The travel costs above are largely fixed. They are about the same whether the procedure costs a little or a great deal, and that decides whether a trip makes financial sense.

A short, cheap procedure. Our zirconia crown page gives $300–1,000 in China against $800–1,900 in the UK, with 5–8 nights in the country. At $95 a night, lodging alone is $475–760, which absorbs the difference before anyone has bought a flight.

A long, expensive one. The saving tends to be substantial when the treatment is expensive at home and you would be paying for it yourself. It helps when most of the cost lies in hospital time, staff and theatre use, which cost less in China, and little of it in an imported device or drug priced similarly everywhere. It helps when a domestically made drug or device is clinically acceptable to you and your doctors and is priced well below the imported alternative, and when the stay is long enough for the saving on the bill to outweigh the fixed costs of travel. Complex surgery, extended courses of cancer treatment and some newer therapies can fall into this group for patients who would otherwise pay private prices.

A case where the saving narrows or disappears. That happens when the treatment is free or heavily subsidised at home and the real cost of staying is time. It happens when the main cost is a patented, imported drug or device with a similar price worldwide, or when you want an international ward or private hospital with full interpreting, whose prices are much closer to those of private care elsewhere. It happens when the treatment needs several trips, each with its own travel costs, and when follow-up at home will be extensive and self-funded.

Do the sum for your own case

The number that should decide the matter is the one on a written quote for your own case, set against what you would pay at home.

  1. Obtain a written quote at home for your case, or establish what you would pay under your insurance or public system.
  2. Obtain a written, dated quote from a hospital in China that names the implant or drug, the ward class and what is included.
  3. Add the travel and time costs listed above. Our cost calculator sets these out line by line.
  4. Add a contingency. We suggest working out what a week’s extra stay would cost.
  5. Compare the two totals in money.

Leave the percentage out of it.

General information, not medical or legal advice. Rules and prices change, so confirm anything that matters with the hospital or the relevant authority before you book.

Personal plan

Have it worked out for your case

Send your records. Within three working days you receive a written plan naming three suitable hospitals, with a budget range and the agencies we would shortlist. It costs $79, paid once, and it is not a diagnosis.

Get a personal plan