How we rate medical-travel agencies
Our full method for rating agencies: eight yes/no checks on transparency, what counts as a pass, how we verify each one and what a rating does not cover.
We rate medical-travel agencies on transparency. Every agency is tested against the same eight checks, and each check has a yes or no answer.
The eight checks
1. Legal entity named and found in the company registry
Pass: the site states the full legal name of the company that contracts with patients, and we find that company, in active status, in the official registry of the country where it says it is registered. A company registered in mainland China must also show its Unified Social Credit Code, the 18-character number on its business licence.
How we verify: we search the public registry. For mainland China, that is the National Enterprise Credit Information Publicity System (gsxt.gov.cn), where we enter the credit code and compare the name, status and registered address with what the site shows. A trading name alone is a fail, as is a company we cannot find. So is a mainland company that shows no credit code, or a code that returns a different company.
2. Website filing (ICP) number shown and valid
Pass: the site displays an ICP filing number, and the public lookup of China’s Ministry of Industry and Information Technology shows it as registered to the same entity and domain.
How we verify: we enter the number and domain into the official lookup. A missing or mismatched number is a fail. A site hosted outside mainland China needs no filing and will fail this check.
3. Service fee and paid relationships published before you enquire
Pass: the agency’s own fee, or the basis on which it is calculated, can be read on the site without submitting a form or sending records. If the agency sells “featured” or “recommended” placement to hospitals or doctors, or pays affiliates or other sites to send it patients, the site says so.
How we verify: we read the site as a visitor would, and we look for paid badges, sponsored listings and affiliate sign-up pages. “Free”, with no explanation of how the agency is paid, is a fail. So is “contact us for pricing”, and so is paid placement or an affiliate programme we find that the site does not disclose.
4. Hospitals and doctors named for each treatment
Pass: for each treatment advertised, the agency names at least one hospital and department, and the doctors or team where it claims a relationship with them.
How we verify: we compare each treatment page with what the hospital publishes about its own departments. One list repeated on every page is a fail.
5. Reviews tied to dated, identifiable cases
Pass: reviews carry a date, the treatment and the hospital, and are hosted on an independent platform or traceable to a case the agency can evidence to us in confidence.
Testimonials and claims on the site must not promise results. A review may describe the service; a quotation presented as proof that treatment works, a success rate with no source, or an unsourced superlative such as “China’s leading” or “the best surgeons” is a fail.
How we verify: we look for dates and detail, and read every testimonial and headline claim. Undated quotations from a first name and a country are a fail. An agency with no reviews also fails, and we note the reason.
6. Medical fees paid directly to the hospital
Pass: the agency states in writing that patients pay medical fees to the hospital and not to the agency, and its terms contain nothing to the contrary.
How we verify: we read the terms and payment pages, and ask the agency to confirm in writing. An agency that collects medical fees itself, or sells an all-in package paid to its own account, fails. So does an agency whose site says hospital fees are “all included” while its contract says they are paid to the hospital separately, because a patient reading the site cannot tell what the price covers.
7. Written agreement and refund terms before payment
Pass: the conditions on which the agency’s fee or any deposit is refunded are published on the site and can be read before payment, set out for each service the agency sells. The agency also gives the patient a written service agreement, with its own reference number, before taking any money.
How we verify: we look for the terms on the site and ask the agency for a blank copy of its agreement. Terms supplied only on request, or only after payment, are a fail. So is a single “refundable” promise with no breakdown by service, and so is an agency that takes payment on the strength of messages or an invoice alone.
8. Numbers and claims consistent across the site
Pass: prices, savings figures, the number of partner hospitals, the founding date, patient numbers and similar claims do not contradict one another between pages or language versions.
How we verify: we compare the main pages, downloadable material and every language version we can read. One unexplained contradiction on a material point is a fail.
What lowers a score
Each failed check costs one point. These findings are the ones we see most often, and each is enough to fail the check shown.
| Finding | Check failed |
|---|---|
| No legal entity named, or no verifiable Unified Social Credit Code for a mainland company | 1 |
| Paid “featured” placement or an affiliate programme that the site does not disclose | 3 |
| Testimonials or claims that promise outcomes, or unsourced superlatives | 5 |
| “All hospital fees included” on the site while the contract says they are paid to the hospital | 6 |
| No written service agreement before payment, or no refund terms per service | 7 |
| Different founding dates, savings figures or patient numbers on different pages | 8 |
How scores are shown
A rating is the number of checks passed, out of eight, with the date we checked, for example “6 of 8, checked 3 November 2026”. Beneath it we list each check as a pass or fail, with a note.
Lists are ordered by score and then alphabetically. No agency can pay for a position.
Re-checks
We aim to re-check every rated agency at least once every six months. We re-check sooner in three cases: an agency tells us it has changed something, a reader reports that a finding is out of date, or we notice a material change.
Right of reply
Before we first publish a rating, we send the agency our findings and allow ten working days for a reply. We correct any finding shown to be mistaken.
After publication, an agency can ask for a correction or a re-check at any time, free of charge, through the contact page. It may also submit a short statement, which we publish beside its rating as the agency’s own words.
We do not remove a rating on request, and we accept no payment to change, remove or delay one. Some agencies pay us a referral fee, which is disclosed next to the agency and has no effect on its score. See how we make money.
What a rating does not cover
A rating measures transparency: whether you can identify the agency, understand its fee and check its claims. Three things are outside it:
- Clinical quality. We do not assess the care at the hospitals an agency works with, or the results of treatment.
- Quality of service. We do not grade how well an agency handles a case.
- Price. A transparent fee can still be a high one.
Eight out of eight is not a recommendation, and a low score is not an accusation of dishonesty. A low score means that, on the date shown, important things could not be verified from outside.