Preview buildPrices are indicative. Hospital records have not yet been checked by phone with each hospital, and the agency ratings are sample data.
Explainers

Proton and heavy ion therapy: who it suits, how long

Proton and heavy ion therapy explained: how particle beams differ from X-rays, which tumours they are considered for and the three to ten weeks to plan for.

Key points

  • Particle beams can deliver a radiation dose to a tumour with less dose to the tissue beyond it.
  • They are an option for selected tumours. For many common cancers, evidence of better results than modern X-ray radiotherapy is limited.
  • A course means daily visits for one to several weeks, plus a week or more of planning beforehand.

Proton therapy and heavy ion therapy are forms of radiotherapy that use beams of particles in place of the X-rays used in conventional treatment. Few centres in the world offer them, which is one reason patients travel. China has a small but growing number of centres, among them a dedicated proton and heavy ion hospital in Shanghai.

They are an option for selected tumours, and should not be read as a better radiotherapy for every cancer. Whether either is right for you is a decision for a radiation oncologist who has seen your scans. This article follows a patient’s path from that first question to the scans that continue years later, in the order the steps happen.

Particle beams stop inside the tumour

Conventional radiotherapy uses high-energy X-rays, also called photons. An X-ray beam gives up energy all the way along its path, so it delivers dose to the tissue in front of the tumour, to the tumour, and to the tissue behind it. Modern techniques concentrate the high dose on the tumour, but the surrounding tissue still receives some.

Charged particles behave differently. They give up relatively little energy as they enter the body, release most of it at a depth that depends on their starting energy, and then stop. The treatment team adjusts the energy to place that peak inside the tumour. There is very little dose beyond it.

Proton therapy uses protons, the nuclei of hydrogen atoms. Its biological effect on tissue is broadly similar to that of X-rays, and its advantage lies in where the dose goes. Heavy ion therapy in practice means carbon ions. They share the physical advantage of protons and also do more biological damage for a given dose, which may be useful against tumours that respond poorly to conventional radiation.

The machinery explains why centres are scarce. Accelerating protons to treatment energies needs a cyclotron or synchrotron and, in most designs, large rotating gantries to direct the beam, housed in a heavily shielded building. Carbon ions are much heavier and need a larger accelerator still. Building and running a centre costs many times what a conventional radiotherapy department costs, and it needs physicists and engineers with scarce skills. Carbon ion centres remain rare, found in only a handful of countries, mostly in East Asia and Europe.

From first question to last scan

1. Ask whether your tumour is one for which particle therapy is considered. It is generally considered where a tumour lies close to structures that tolerate radiation badly, or where reducing the dose to healthy tissue matters especially. The situations commonly discussed are tumours in children, where sparing growing tissue may reduce long-term effects, and tumours at the base of the skull and along the spine, such as chordoma and chondrosarcoma, which lie beside the brainstem and spinal cord. Some tumours of the eye, and some brain and head and neck tumours, are on the list too. So are tumours in an area that has already been irradiated, where the surrounding tissue can take little more. Carbon ions are sometimes considered for tumours regarded as resistant to conventional radiation, including some sarcomas and some tumours of the salivary glands.

Centres also treat more common cancers, such as those of the prostate, liver, lung and pancreas. Here the case is less settled. For many common cancers, good evidence that particle therapy gives better results than the best modern X-ray radiotherapy is limited, and trials are continuing.

2. Compare plans for your own case. A better distribution of dose on a planning screen does not always translate into a better outcome for the patient. A recommendation should therefore come from a comparison of plans for your case, and ideally from a doctor who can offer both kinds of treatment.

Put the question to the centre directly: why does it recommend particle therapy for your case in preference to X-ray radiotherapy, and how many patients with your type of tumour has it treated?

3. Send your records for remote review. The centre asks for scans, pathology reports and a treatment history, and decides whether the case is suitable. Expect to send the imaging files as well as the reports.

Because capacity is limited, centres select patients. A centre may decline a case because it judges that particle therapy offers no advantage. Take a refusal on those grounds seriously.

4. Work out how long you will be away, then arrange to stay that long. Ask the centre how many fractions are planned and how many weeks to allow in total. The arithmetic runs like this. Planning on site commonly takes one to two weeks before the first treatment. Proton courses commonly run for several weeks, in line with conventional radiotherapy schedules. Carbon ion courses often use fewer fractions and can be shorter, from about one week to about four in many protocols. Add some margin for machine maintenance, and a patient should usually plan for somewhere between three and ten weeks on site.

A course can outlast a short visa-free stay. Check the rules for your passport in our guide to the China visa for medical travel. Treatment is usually outpatient, so budget for somewhere to live nearby; the cost calculator has a line for it. Ask, too, what the centre’s estimate includes and what records you will receive in English.

5. Consultation and planning on site. After arrival, you are examined. Planning scans are taken in the treatment position, often with a mask or mould made to hold you still.

6. Treatment. Treatment is given in daily sessions called fractions, usually five days a week. The number of fractions sets the length of this stage, which is why two patients at the same centre can be there for different periods.

7. Review and discharge. You are seen during the course and at its end, and given a summary for your doctors at home.

8. Follow-up at home. Scans and reviews continue for years. Agree before you travel who will do them at home. Our guide to aftercare and follow-up covers the handover.

Time on site, stage by stage

The table gathers the timings from the steps above. Read the right-hand column as the part you should confirm with the centre, because each figure is typical and none is a promise for your case.

Stage Where it happens Typical time Confirm with the centre
Remote review From home, by file transfer Before you travel Which imaging files and reports it needs
Consultation and planning On site One to two weeks before the first treatment Whether a mask or mould will be made
Proton course On site, usually outpatient Several weeks, five days a week The number of fractions planned
Carbon ion course On site, usually outpatient About one to four weeks in many protocols The number of fractions planned
Margin On site An allowance for machine maintenance How much margin the centre advises
Whole stay On site Usually three to ten weeks The centre’s own total for your case
Follow-up At home Years Who at home will do the scans and reviews

Ask the centre for its own estimate for your case before you book anything.

General information, not medical or legal advice. Rules and prices change, so confirm anything that matters with the hospital or the relevant authority before you book.

Personal plan

Have it worked out for your case

Send your records. Within three working days you receive a written plan naming three suitable hospitals, with a budget range and the agencies we would shortlist. It costs $79, paid once, and it is not a diagnosis.

Get a personal plan