Preview buildPrices are indicative. Hospital records have not yet been checked by phone with each hospital, and the agency ratings are sample data.
Explainers

JCI accreditation: why most top Chinese hospitals lack it

What JCI accreditation tells you about a hospital, why most leading Chinese public hospitals have not sought it, and which quality signals to check instead.

Key points

  • JCI assesses a hospital's safety systems and processes. It does not rank doctors or predict outcomes.
  • Most leading Chinese public hospitals rely on the national grading system and have not sought JCI.
  • Check any accreditation at its source, and look at the department's experience with your condition.

The accreditation logo seen most often on medical travel websites is the gold seal of Joint Commission International, or JCI. Readers who look for it in China find that many of the most respected hospitals lack it.

The seal is worth noting when a hospital has it, particularly a private one. Its absence should not put you off a leading Chinese public hospital. Two questions matter more: does this department treat many patients like you, and will it answer you in writing? No seal answers either.

What a JCI survey checks

Joint Commission International is the international arm of the Joint Commission, a non-profit body that accredits hospitals in the United States. A hospital applies for accreditation and pays for it. Surveyors visit, review documents and interview staff, and they follow individual patients’ care through the hospital to see whether written policies are carried out in practice.

The standards cover how patients are identified and how staff communicate, the handling of high-risk medicines, and procedures to ensure the right operation on the right patient at the right site. They cover infection prevention and harm from falls, patients’ rights, consent and complaints, the checking of staff qualifications, and the safety of buildings and equipment and the way the hospital is governed. Accreditation lasts for a fixed term, three years at the time of writing, after which the hospital is surveyed again.

A current accreditation tells you that, at the survey, an outside body found recognisable safety and quality systems, documented so an international surveyor could follow them. For a patient far from home, that is useful, and it is all the seal tells you. A hospital is accredited or it is not, so the seal ranks nobody. It does not assess individual doctors or the skill of a particular surgeon, and it publishes no survival or complication rates. It is granted to a specific organisation, sometimes to a specific site or programme, and may not cover what you assume. A seal on a website may refer to an accreditation that has since lapsed. And a hospital that has never applied has failed nothing.

Why the big public hospitals have not applied

Private hospitals that serve foreigners, and some public ones, have sought JCI. Most large public teaching hospitals have not. They answer to a domestic system of regulation and grading, which is what the health authorities, Chinese patients and the state insurance scheme look to. International accreditation is partly a signal to foreign patients and international insurers, and these hospitals already work at or beyond capacity with domestic demand. The process is also expensive and takes a great deal of staff time.

None of this is a judgement either way. In China the missing seal says much less than it would where private hospitals compete for foreign patients.

The designation to learn instead is Tertiary Grade A, often written “Grade 3A” or, in Chinese, sanjia. The health authorities classify hospitals in three tiers by size, function and range of services; tertiary hospitals are the large referral and teaching hospitals, and within a tier, A is the highest grade. Most hospitals that take foreign patients for complex care are Grade 3A. There are a great many, and the grade reflects the whole hospital, so it will not tell you whether a given department is strong in your condition. Our guide to how Chinese hospitals work explains the tiers.

Judge the department, and check every badge at its source

No single badge settles the question. Ask whether the department is designated by the health authorities as a national or provincial key clinical specialty, and whether the hospital is a national centre for the field. Ask how many patients with your condition the team treats in a year and how many such procedures the surgeon performs; experience with a procedure is among the more useful things you can ask about. Reputational rankings of Chinese hospitals and specialties, published by academic institutions in China, measure standing among peers and research output. They do not measure outcomes, so treat them as one view among several. A specialist at home may know the team by its publications.

Then verify. JCI publishes a list of the organisations it accredits, searchable by country. A hospital’s grade can be confirmed through the relevant Chinese health authority or the hospital’s official website. Do not rely on a logo shown by a hospital, and still less on one shown by an agency.

Our hospital profiles record each hospital’s grade and any international accreditation, with the date we checked.

General information, not medical or legal advice. Rules and prices change, so confirm anything that matters with the hospital or the relevant authority before you book.

Personal plan

Have it worked out for your case

Send your records. Within three working days you receive a written plan naming three suitable hospitals, with a budget range and the agencies we would shortlist. It costs $79, paid once, and it is not a diagnosis.

Get a personal plan